Escape to Shelter Island

A private retreat with three king bedrooms, private seasonal pool and space to slow down.

Shelter Island, NY, United States

41 SOUTH MENANTIC

Escape to Shelter Island in a private family home designed for relaxed stays with family and friends. With three king bedrooms (plus a bunk room), generous indoor-outdoor living spaces and a large private yard, it’s the perfect place to unplug. Explore beaches, Mashomack Preserve, Sylvester Manor, North Fork vineyards, Greenport and Sag Harbor, then return home to cook, dine and unwind together. Private pool open seasonally from late-May through mid-September.

8 guests
4 bedrooms
2.5 bathrooms

Good to know

The pool is seasonal and typically open from late May through mid-September; it is not heated. The home has three king bedrooms plus a bunk room, comfortably accommodating up to eight guests. Shelter Island is reached by a short ferry ride from either Greenport or North Haven, and having a car is recommended for exploring the island and surrounding area. The house is a private family home in a quiet residential setting, so we ask guests to enjoy it with care. The best part of staying here is slowing down to island time: mornings by the pool, afternoons at the beach or exploring the island, and evenings cooking, grilling and relaxing at home.

House Rules

We want you to settle in and enjoy the house as your own. We just ask that you treat our home, property and neighbors with care. Maximum 8 overnight guests. The home is designed for families and small groups, not parties or events. No parties or events without prior approval. Please respect our neighbors. Keep outdoor noise to a reasonable level, particularly in the evening. No smoking or vaping inside the house. Pool use is at your own risk. Children must be supervised by an adult at all times. No glass in the pool area. Trampoline use requires a signed waiver. Guests who have not completed the waiver may not use the trampoline. Children must be supervised by an adult. Pets only with prior approval. Registered guests only unless otherwise agreed in advance. No commercial photography or filming without prior written approval. Check-in is from 4:00 PM and check-out is by 10:00 AM. Most importantly, relax and enjoy Shelter Island. We want our home to feel like your home while you're here.

What this place offers

Common

  • Air conditioning
  • Cooking basics Pots and pans, oil, salt and pepper
  • Dishes and silverware
  • Dryer In the building, free or for a fee
  • Hair dryer
  • Heating Central heating or a heater in the listing
  • Kitchen Space where guests can cook their own meals
  • Dedicated workspace
  • Pool
  • TV
  • Washing Machine
  • Wifi

Bathroom

  • Bathtub
  • Hot Water

Bedroom and laundry

  • Bed linens
  • Hangers
  • Iron
  • Room-darkening shades
  • Clothing storage

Common

  • Air conditioning
  • Cooking basics Pots and pans, oil, salt and pepper
  • Dishes and silverware
  • Dryer In the building, free or for a fee
  • Hair dryer
  • Heating Central heating or a heater in the listing
  • Kitchen Space where guests can cook their own meals
  • Dedicated workspace
  • Pool
  • TV
  • Washing Machine
  • Wifi

Bathroom

  • Bathtub
  • Hot Water

Bedroom and laundry

  • Bed linens
  • Hangers
  • Iron
  • Room-darkening shades
  • Clothing storage

Entertainment

  • Exercise equipment

Family

  • Pack 'n Play/travel crib

Heating and cooling

  • Indoor fireplace

Home safety

  • Carbon monoxide detector
  • Fire extinguisher
  • First aid kit
  • Smoke detector

Kitchen and dining

  • Baking sheet
  • Barbecue utensils
  • Coffee maker
  • Dining table
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Wine glasses

Outdoors

  • BBQ grill
  • Beach essentials Beach towels, umbrella, beach blanket, snorkeling gear
  • Garden or backyard
  • Outdoor seating

Parking and facilities

  • Free parking on premises

Services

  • Long term stays allowed Allow stay for 28 days or more

Accessibility and Availability

Find us

Sorry we're unable to show you the location for this property

Approximate location. Full address will be provided on booking.